This is a story about a dog that bit a mailman. Only this time, the mailman bit back – against the dog owner’s insurance company.
Harry Evans was delivering mail in 1980, when a dog ran out and bit him on the forearm, causing nerve damage, a permanent scar and an atrophied biceps muscle. The dog owner had a $25,000 liability policy with Continental Insurance Company.
Shortly after the incident, Mr. Evans’ original lawyer demanded that the insurance company pay the policy limits. They refused.
Continental eventually offered $10,000 and then very slowly increased their offers until, finally, two years later, they coughed up the full $25,000 policy limits. In the meantime, nothing had changed about the case. All of the pertinent medical information about Mr. Evans’ injuries was included with the very first letter from his lawyer to Continental.
Mr. Evans’ original lawyer then brought us in to sue Continental for bad faith in an insurance dispute lawsuit.
We alleged that the company violated the Insurance Code by delaying payment of a legitimate claim without good cause. The two-year delay in paying the $25,000, we argued, was simply an attempt by the insurance company to save money at Mr. Evans’ expense.
The case proceeded to trial. A key ingredient at trial was the testimony of an attorney who was formerly employed by Continental. He had taken over the handling of Mr. Evans’ dog bite case for the insurance company after two years of stalling by other employees, and he immediately recognized that the case was worth $25,000 and that the prior negotiations were not in good faith.
He later left Continental in a dispute over its handling of an insurance claim asserted by his wife. The company stalled and delayed on his wife’s claim, just as they had done to Mr. Evans and others!
At trial in the bad faith case, the former Continental attorney testified that not only was the company’s handling of Mr. Evans’ claim in bad faith, but it was consistent with the company’s normal business practices.
Rather than pay claims in a timely and fair manner, Continental would “low ball” plaintiffs, in the hope that many would need the money and would accept these unfair offers. A few plaintiffs would have the backbone to keep fighting, and in those cases, Continental would eventually pay what the case was worth. In the meantime, however, the company saved millions of dollars by this unfair practice.
After just five hours of deliberations, the jury returned a verdict for $1,075,000, which consisted of $75,000 to compensate Mr. Evans for the emotional distress that he suffered while the insurance company delayed paying his claim and $1,000,000 in punitive damages to punish the insurance company for its regular business practice of “low ball” settlement offers.
My family experienced a tremendous loss as a result of my father’s death. During the entire process of investigation and settlement of our case, we were treated with the utmost professionalism by the Booth & Koskoff attorneys and staff.
– Dale Magner
“Because of Roger’s experience and professionalism, I was able to focus on the others things I needed to do for my brother to care for him during this time. He was a godsend, and I would highly recommend Roger and his staff.”
– Penny Vincelli
The lawyers and staff at Booth & Koskoff were efficient, thorough, helpful and always available, even on weekends. I am very pleased with my overall experience, and I would recommend Booth & Koskoff to anyone who needs an excellent attorney.
– Keith Schultz
When I met with Roger, he was honest, genuine, and straight-forward on how we would proceed. Roger took a leap of faith when taking this case. He trusted what I said to be true, and wasn’t afraid to proceed.
– Cynthia Mitchell
“We felt lucky like we were referred to Booth & Koskoff by someone we trusted. Richard’s professionalism and tenacity showed that he definitely was in our court.”
– John Mahoney
“From the moment I contacted Booth & Koskoff from my hospital bed to the eventual settlement of my case, I experienced nothing but outstanding assistance and representation.”
– Claire Rexon
“Mr. Booth did an incredible job resolving the case for us, and we are very thankful for the successful ending to our lawsuit. Thank you for your hard work Mr. Booth. You will always be our family lawyer and friend.”
– Sam Kirakosyan