SETTLEMENT : Husband injured and wife killed when rear-ended by City maintenance truck
Can a driver be held responsible for an accident caused by sun glare and its resulting momentary blindness?
On January 15, 1995, Michael and Joyce Zitz-Evancich were stopped in 5:00 traffic on the transition road between westbound Simi Valley Freeway and southbound Golden State Freeway. The couple’s sedan was sitting in the second lane when a five-ton Department of Street Maintenance truck slammed into their rear-end. The truck driver later claimed sun glare caused momentarily blindness (sunset on that day would have occurred at approximately 5:07 p.m.). He asserted that that his temporary blindness caused the accident .
The force of the truck’s impact immediately killed Joyce, then 35-years-old. Michael Zitz-Evancich reportedly went into convulsions when paramedics arrived. The truck driver was found uninjured. Michael Zitz-Evancich was taken to Holy Cross Medical Center where doctors listed him as in serious condition and later determined he had suffered significant brain damage. Those personal injuries, and the traumatic death of his wife, completely altered the projection of his life.
Firm partner Larry Booth represented Zitz-Evancich alongside Johanna Hansen in a lawsuit against the city, owners of the maintenance truck and employers of the driver. Booth emphasized the negligence of the driver and the severity of the accident, saying, “The car was just mashed.”
The lawsuit filed against the city of Los Angeles sought financial reparations both for the wrongful death of Joyce Zitz-Evancich and for the personal injuries and emotional pain and suffering sustained by Michael Zitz-Evancich. Over a year after the accident, he continued to suffer from his injuries and required limited at-home care.
Deputy City Attorney Herbert Seiden represented the city in the case. While he did not discuss the details of the case publicly, the city argued that the fatal accident was not the truck driver’s fault due to his being momentarily blinded by the setting sun.
Sun glare is not an uncommon defense in these types of accidents as it is an easy and convenient means of covering up what is in truth a case of driver negligence. Several courts have outright rejected the defense of ‘sun glare’ holding that because sunrises and sunsets are a daily and natural occurrence, drivers should anticipate occasional sun glare during these time periods and act responsibly. In line with this, Booth and colleagues were able to successfully argue against this defense.
On June 25, 1996, the Los Angeles City council voted to settle the case out of court. They agreed to a $5 million settlement. Michael Zitz-Evancich accepted the council’s settlement.
When I met with Roger, he was honest, genuine, and straight-forward on how we would proceed. Roger took a leap of faith when taking this case. He trusted what I said to be true, and wasn’t afraid to proceed.
– Cynthia Mitchell
My family experienced a tremendous loss as a result of my father’s death. During the entire process of investigation and settlement of our case, we were treated with the utmost professionalism by the Booth & Koskoff attorneys and staff.
– Dale Magner
“Mr. Booth did an incredible job resolving the case for us, and we are very thankful for the successful ending to our lawsuit. Thank you for your hard work Mr. Booth. You will always be our family lawyer and friend.”
– Sam Kirakosyan
“We felt lucky like we were referred to Booth & Koskoff by someone we trusted. Richard’s professionalism and tenacity showed that he definitely was in our court.”
– John Mahoney
The lawyers and staff at Booth & Koskoff were efficient, thorough, helpful and always available, even on weekends. I am very pleased with my overall experience, and I would recommend Booth & Koskoff to anyone who needs an excellent attorney.
– Keith Schultz
“From the moment I contacted Booth & Koskoff from my hospital bed to the eventual settlement of my case, I experienced nothing but outstanding assistance and representation.”
– Claire Rexon
“Because of Roger’s experience and professionalism, I was able to focus on the others things I needed to do for my brother to care for him during this time. He was a godsend, and I would highly recommend Roger and his staff.”
– Penny Vincelli